The Fallacy of Productivity

You may have seen the memes on social media, things like Shakespeare having written King Lear while quarantined during the plague. Or heard of people using this time of sheltering-in-place to learn or perfect a new skill. Or to dive into that stack of books they’ve been meaning to read. Or to write a book. Oh, and home improvement projects, too! To the casual (or not-so-casual) observer, it all speaks to so much PRODUCTIVITY.

You might be sitting at home thinking, “Why aren’t I as productive as everyone else? Why am I struggling to get out of bed and walk in my pajamas to my ‘office’ across the hall? Why am I struggling to complete basic tasks, like laundry, vacuuming, or doing dishes?” For me, my creative output has been zilch. Stories to revise, stories to submit to journals…none of it is happening. (In addition to this creative decline, I also just moved and am surrounded by boxes and a disorganization so profound that it feels distinctly like the opposite of productivity.)

The fact of the matter, though, is that you don’t have to be productive right now. Teachers thrown into online teaching don’t have to shine at it; they just have to get by. Parents thrown into homeschooling their children don’t have to create lesson plans; they just have to do what they can. We’re all just doing what we can. Whether you have to physically go to work because you’re considered essential or whether you’ve been furloughed from your job or whether you’re working from home, the fact of the matter is that many people are anxious, depressed, fearful; the fact of the matter is that many of us are experiencing grief at different levels.

Many of us simply cannot be as productive when we’re dealing with stress and the emotional toll of a worldwide crisis, such as COVID-19.

And that’s okay. It really is.

Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs

I’m not a psychologist, but I do remember my basic psychology course from college twenty-five years ago. For many people, but maybe especially writers, artists, and other creative types, our vision of what “productivity” means falls within the top level of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, that being the level of “self-actualization.” For me, being creative often equals being productive. And I haven’t felt that spark of creativity for many weeks. That “spark of creativity,” though, is part of my essence–part of what makes me feel like me. I feel empty without it.

At the same time, though, I have it better than a lot of people. I already work from home; my job–my business–is intact. I have both shelter and food. All my basic needs are met. But you know what I feel? Guilt. I feel guilt for feeling empty when I have so much to be thankful for. I can only imagine what it must feel like to not have your basic needs met–basic needs are the foundation of Maslow’s hierarchy. And right above that is safety and security. One’s health falls under safety. It’s frightening to go to the grocery store and think: Does that person have the virus? Is the virus living on this bag of chips? This is followed by: Am I being paranoid? Crazy? Too obsessed with cleanliness? (The answer is no.)

Not only that, but we don’t know when any of this will end. We may not have confidence in the people in charge. We may read the scientific articles and understand fully what we’re up against, yet we may feel frustration with the people who don’t seem to get it, who instead gather in groups on the beach or as a congregation in a church. This insecurity paints itself as anger, frustration, and heightened anxiety.

It’s been said that naming your emotions can help alleviate some of the anxiety that you’re feeling about an event or situation. For me, it helps to state bluntly and honestly what I miss. To do this, though, I have to let go of the guilt I experience for being seemingly petty or simplistic.

What I Miss

I miss people. I enjoy the Zoom meetings and social-media interactions just fine, but I miss people. In-person people. I went for a run today and was so delighted to see other people out (all keeping our distance); we all waved, said, “Hi!” It seems clear that other people miss people, too. And if you’re following Maslow’s hierarchy, this sense of socialization–of belonging, of interacting–is right there above safety and security, another step closer to self-actualization.

I miss art, poetry, and other cultural events. I’m typically inspired by other creative people. Book readings, poetry readings, art shows, museums. Is this why my own creativity is lagging right now?

I miss being able to go to coffeehouses. To work among other people and not just alone (albeit with my dog) in my house.

I miss traveling. I had planned to go the ACES National Conference (an editing conference) at the end of April, a conference that was, of course, cancelled. I miss experiencing new places and new situations and meeting new people.

It’s Okay to Feel

I’m thankful for what I have. I’m SO grateful. But it’s okay to be both thankful and sad.

It’s okay to grieve. Many have lost jobs, family members, and access to basic needs and safety. Allow yourself to grieve.

It’s okay to not be writing or reading. I’ve heard people say that we *should* be journaling–recording history as it unfolds–but it’s okay to not be doing that, too. A lot of people are just trying to get through each day.

It’s okay not to blog. It took me a long time to finally sit down and write this post. I had to process my feelings first, which I did in an early draft. Writing is therapeutic, but it’s hard to write if your mind is spinning.

It’s okay to feel numb or to feel everything all at once.

Allow yourself to feel what you feel.

I write these things not just for my readers but also for myself, as a way of breaking out of what feels like an unproductive slump. The world–our lives–have changed, and we don’t know when anything will be “normal” again.

But “normal” is subjective anyway. You need only be as productive as you’re able to be, regardless of whether there’s a pandemic or not.


15 Comments

Joe Artz · April 4, 2020 at 11:55 am

This is inspiring to read. You gave not just shape, but also voice to thoughts and feelings that been eddy-ing in my mind the past few days. This morning, I rescued myself by saying “Artz, do one thing – anything – just to say you’ve done something.” So I took the shopvac back to the basement where it belongs and that felt so good, I got an empty tub from the junk room and filled it all the beer and wine bottles that have piling up waiting to be hauled to the recycling place.

    Jessica Klimesh · April 4, 2020 at 1:49 pm

    Thanks for the feedback! I’m glad it was helpful. I feel like if I unpack one or two of my moving boxes a day, it counts as being productive (even if everything is still completely unorganized!).

Alice · April 4, 2020 at 4:05 pm

A very insightful, reassuring post. Thanks, Jessica

    Jessica Klimesh · April 4, 2020 at 4:06 pm

    Thanks!

Amy Christensen · April 4, 2020 at 7:40 pm

Jess, this is perfect and just what so many of us need to hear. These are difficult times and it is a given that we are going to feel stress and even grief, not necessarily because we lost someone, but because we have lost what is normal. I wrote a post a few days ago for the blog and one of the things I said was to let yourself feel these feelings, whether it is fear, sadness, frustration or some blend of all of them. Pretending things aren’t hard, when they are is not going to be good for our mental health and that is something we have to prioritize, but as much as our physical health. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. – Amy
https://stylingrannymama.com/

    Jessica Klimesh · April 4, 2020 at 9:13 pm

    Thanks for reading!

Gloria C. · April 5, 2020 at 10:07 am

Hi Jessica, I love this piece! You know those pieces that really speak to you and are exactly what you need at a particular point in time? This is one of them. I wondered if others were having a tough time writing, or if it was just me. Funny how we think “everyone else” is getting so much more done or has it together more than we do, when in fact we have no idea what’s really going on with other people. There’s nothing like a worldwide crisis to kill one’s creative mojo. How interdependent and connected our world, how fragile it all is.

I liked the HBS article you linked to about grief. Our collective grief about the plague can easily become paralyzing. Joe’s self-talk about making yourself just do one thing is helpful. If we can accomplish one thing a day through this time, and remember there is an end, we can get through it. Who knows, maybe one thing a day can grow into two or more things, until we eventually regain our productivity.

    Jessica Klimesh · April 5, 2020 at 12:33 pm

    Thanks, Gloria! I’m so glad you found it helpful; it’s certainly helpful to me knowing that other people are feeling similarly. And, yes, setting a goal of accomplishing just one thing a day is a great way to inch back into things. We need to be easy on ourselves; it’s not like this is a “stay-cation.” It might seem like it is, but it’s actually quite different. Thanks for reading!

N.K. McGlinn · April 5, 2020 at 10:57 am

Hi Jessica,
Nadja here! Thanks very much for this wonderful, thoughtful, calm and honest, and very supportive piece.

I have a blog-in-name-only that I “should” be writing in, or even posting one thing in — it’s been “there” (named, skeleton partly formed, ghostly ideas wafting around the bones, but unborn) looking down on me accusingly but now, I can politely flip it the bird. With a smile. But who knows…

I’ve kind of gotten somewhat agoraphobic, and keep telling myself the weather is so great, go walk. I plan to do it, to have both of us go (wow, Joe, 3 or 4 miles?) and then find myself seeing an obvious reason not to. Emotionally it’s the strangest mix of both a kind of brainless excitement/agitation about being in the middle of a disaster movie, and deep grief about being in the middle of a slow-moving hurricane-like disaster. When my mind does inventory of all the things falling apart, cascading down to so many painful levels, my stomach begins to drop and I must pull back to my own life, into my study, behind our windows and doors and into my very limited reality. Maybe a kind of emotional agoraphobia?

But I did, before this happened, buy a Yamaha keyboard, and I am relearning to play the piano. The practice time is a structure, and the need to focus is functioning like a meditation, because one second of space out and the Yamaha lets me know it 🙂 Sometimes even that playing brings up a kind of half-assed guilt (image of Nero fiddling) until I remember that the image is a myth. And Jupiter knows, the last thing we need right now is more bullshit.

Anyway dear Jessica, thanks for this, may you and yours not be infected by either the Corona virus or a conspiracy theory attached to its tail!

Nadja

    Jessica Klimesh · April 5, 2020 at 12:29 pm

    Thanks, Nadja! I get that feeling of agoraphobia, and I like what you say about it being “the strangest mix of both a kind of brainless excitement/agitation…and deep grief.” It really took me quite a while to process what I was feeling and why; curtailing anger has sometimes been the hardest. Focusing on what I can control is something I have to keep reminding myself to do.

Sherry Lohman · April 5, 2020 at 7:32 pm

So good– thanks, Jessica!

    Jessica Klimesh · April 5, 2020 at 8:05 pm

    Thanks, Sherry!

Shirley Hilton · April 7, 2020 at 8:53 pm

Nice piece, Jessica. It’s good to see that people are willing to talk about their emotions. I like Joe’s suggestion to “do one thing”.

There’s always a lot to do at home, and I can’t seem to get to any of it! Then one day I had an idea. I threw away my “to-do” list and started making a “ta-da” list. Reverse psychology. You can only record something AFTER it’s done. Some days it has one thing on it. Some days more.

I too feel a great deal of gratitude that my basic needs are met; so many people don’t. And I mourn for those who die alone and for their loved ones who can’t say goodbye.

Most days I feel like the world is moving in slow motion. That I’m waiting for something but don’t know what it is and have no idea when it will come. Limbo?

    Jessica Klimesh · April 8, 2020 at 9:15 am

    I love the “ta-da” list idea! I get the “moving in slow motion” feeling, too. That could stem from the fact that we don’t know what’s ahead. That’s, of course, always true; but with this virus, there’s even more uncertainty. We can’t plan for a Fourth of July barbecue, for example, or even a summer vacation. For me, it’s kind of a feeling of “floating” and not knowing when we’ll reach a shore.

N.K. McGlinn · April 8, 2020 at 1:15 pm

Wow, that exchange, Shirley and Jessica, nails it for me. Gratitude, uncertainty, waiting for something, slow-motion. Thank you for the ta-dah Shirley, and good to hear from you. Thanks Jessica for creating this little arena where we can talk about it with trusted people.

Leave a Reply!

© 2024 JEK Proofreading & Editing